By Brian Mengini
Spoiler alert: Local playwright Andrea Kennedy Hart’s, “The Toughest Boy in Philadelphia, ” is based on a true story of “Whistling” Jack McConnell. It follows the life of Florence Gray as she struggles with the void of her absentee mother as well as her own gender confusion. Her turmoil leads her to adopt a male persona, “Whistling” Jack McConnell, who joins the Irish mob and indeed becomes “the Toughest Boy in Philadelphia.”
At the start of the play, in Philadelphia’s Luna Theater, Tessie Belle played by Michelle Pauls, opens with dialogue dressed in a tux. You are then taken to Florence’s (KO DelMarcelle) childhood and her early troubles with boys and her tough guy/girl persona start to emerge. Her grandfather (played by Susan Giddings—both male and female parts of the play are performed by women), struggles to keep Florence happy and well adjusted and the rest of the world at bay. They eventually leave Ohio for greener pastures and a fresh start in Philadelphia. It is here where Florence really starts to identify more as a male.
As Jack, she meets and falls in love with Lettie, herself a male impersonator though for Lettie it’s about show business not gender confusion. As happened in real life, Jack is only found out when she is defending herself in a paternity suit.
Having all the roles played by women adds another layer of compassion and insight to this play, a tale of women’s rights, human rights, love, and acceptance. Director John Doyle’s production is captivating and often funny and the use of simple sets and costumes allows this compelling story to take center stage.
“The Toughest Boy in Philadelphia” will run through June 29. Tickets are $20 and available via ticketleap.
